Between seven books and eight movies, it’s nearly impossible to look back and think of one favorite moment, person, or place from the Harry Potter series. Luckily, you’ll never be forced to do that . . . except in this special “Would you rather?” game! Potterheads will find themselves stumped when faced with these hypothetical scenarios, but deciding between two options is way too fun to miss. Ahead, answer more than 30 tough decisions about your favorite magical world — just don’t hate us for number 20.
— Additional reporting by Lauren Harano