Being on The Bachelor usually means one thing: a lot of crying. That’s why the contestants need a mascara that can hold up to all the drama (or risk having a Hannah B. moment). This season, throughout all the drama and countless teary confessionals, Madison Prewitt’s makeup look has been particularly gorgeous. If you’re wondering what mascara she uses to get that look, we’ve got good news for you: it’s actually a super common brand that’s affordable and accessible for anyone.
On an early episode of The Bachelor, Prewitt is shown applying mascara in preparation for her date with Peter. Eagle-eyed viewers zoomed in on the mascara tube and figured it out: Prewitt’s mascara is Maybelline Lash Stiletto Ultimate Length Waterproof Mascara ($10). The brush and the mascara both are designed to lengthen lashes and apply a shiny black coat for that camera-ready look. Most importantly of all, of course, is the fact that it’s waterproof — or, at least, this version is; the same exact mascara also comes in a “washable” version that dissolves in just water. For all your pool party or rose ceremony needs, though, the waterproof version is your best friend.
As a stylish woman who also knows how to work hard (she works with foster families and hopes to open an orphanage, according to her official ABC bio), it’s no surprise that Prewitt’s makeup choices are refreshingly ordinary. While other elements of The Bachelor style seem incredibly unattainable for viewers (those glamorous wardrobes! the international locales! the exclusive dates!), it’s great to see the contestants with some more down-to-earth choices.
Maybelline Lash Stiletto Ultimate Length Waterproof Mascara